People fight about two things in divorce: kids and money. Oddly, people spend more money fighting about kids than they spend money fighting about money. Actually, that’s not entirely odd since kids are more important than money, but anyway.
The most contentious part about the fight over kids is figuring out physical and legal custody. Physical custody is where kids physically spend their time, and specifically where they spend their overnights. Physical custody is often called visitation or parent-time. The other aspect of custody is legal custody. Legal custody relates to who gets to make big life decisions for kids. It’s legal custody I want to talk about for a minute.
The first thing to understand about legal custody is it only applies to certain big aspects of kids’ lives –decisions regarding religion, schooling, medicine and healthcare, and extracurricular activities. So, if one parent were to have sole legal custody, that doesn’t mean that parent gets to make every decision imaginable and cut out the other parent. That’s not how parenting works, even among divorced parents. Divorce parents are still parents, and they have to work together for the good of their children.
Get Clear Guidance for Your Divorce
In Utah joint legal custody is the norm, and there’s good reason for this. Human minds work better as a team, and we usually come up with better ideas when we work in conjunction with others. Even parents who don’t like each other will almost always come together, discuss what’s best, and do what’s right for their kids. Because this is the reality of most Utah divorces and break-up situations, joint legal custody makes a lot of sense and is best for kids.
A Calmer, Clearer Way Through Divorce
A prime example of this is braces. Braces are usually not medically necessary. Despite this, almost every divorced couple I know talks to each other cordially and comes up with a plan to get Junior his braces when the time comes. They talk about the who, the when, the cost, and they do it for the good of their child.
As with anything in divorce and child custody cases, there will be bumps in the road. Parents won’t always agree about everything. This is why, even when you share joint legal custody, one parent is usually awarded final decision-making authority. This means parents still discuss all major decisions, and talk through any disagreements, but when there is a serious disagreement that cannot be solved through discussion (and many times mediation), then one parent is able to make the final decision.
Judges will almost always designate a final decision-maker simply because judges do not want parents coming before them whenever a disagreement arises.
If one parent really feels the other parent’s decision hurts the kids, then there is always the option to take the matter to court to have it reviewed. In our office we have seen thousands of cases, and maybe a handful (three to five) have gone back before a judge to address legal custody issues. It just doesn’t happen that often. (When it does, it’s usually a situation in which one parent wishes to change schools and the other parent disagrees with the change.)
So, again, joint legal custody is the norm in Utah, and for good reason. It requires parents to discuss major life decisions and work with each other for the good of their kids. Even though it may be hard, this process usually creates the best results for families, even divorced families.
Appendix of Utah Laws Regarding Joint Legal Custody
Utah Code, Section 30-3-10.1. Definitions — Joint legal custody — Joint physical custody.
As used in this chapter:
| (1) | “Joint legal custody”:
|
Utah Code, Section 30-3-10.2. Joint custody order — Factors for court determination — Public assistance.
| (1) | The court may order joint legal custody or joint physical custody or both if one or both parents have filed a parenting plan in accordance with Section 30-3-10.8 and it determines that joint legal custody or joint physical custody or both is in the best interest of the child. |
| (2) | In determining whether the best interest of a child will be served by ordering joint legal or physical custody, the court shall consider the following factors:
|
