I Don’t Like the Decision my Commissioner Made; What Can I Do?

When it comes to divorce and family law cases, Utah is a bit different from other states.

For example, we use a commissioner system, which is pretty rare in America.

A commissioner is not quite a judge, but acts as something like an under-judge in divorce and family law cases.

What this means is a commissioner handles almost all aspects of a family law case, but he or she does not actually have decision-making authority.

What a commissioner does is hear disputes and make recommendations to a judge, then the judge signs off on those recommendations which makes them an order of the court.

Commissioners hear Temporary Orders, Motions for Order to Show Cause, Protective Orders, Temporary Restraining Orders, Pretrials, etc. Essentially, they hear and make recommendations on every aspect of a case with the exception those things right before trial.

So, commissioners have a lot of power in Utah divorce cases.

But what happens if your commissioner gets something wrong and makes a wrong decision? What can you do?

There really are two options.

First, you can deal with the wrong decision and let it go. I know, not a great option, but you have to decide if the decision was about something important enough to object to.

Second, you can object to the commissioner’s decision (technically, we call it a recommendation).

If you object, you will need to file a formal objection with the court. That needs to happen “within 14 days after the recommendation is made in open court or, if the court commissioner takes the matter under advisement, within 14 days after the minute entry of the recommendation is served.”

Your objection will be forwarded to the judge on your case, and you will have a hearing with that judge to discuss why you think the commissioner was mistaken.

Now, when an objection goes to the judge, the judge will have one of two hearings: (1) regarding law only, or (2) regarding law and facts (i.e., evidentiary hearing).

The distinction here is really important.

If the hearing regards law only, then you will argue only legal reasons why the commissioner was mistaken. You will not be able to introduce new evidence or present witnesses or live testimony. Also, the judge will assume the commissioner’s recommendation was correct and require you to show clear legal arguments why he or she was wrong. Hearings regarding only law are difficult to win.

If the hearing regards law and facts (i.e., it’s an evidentiary hearing), then the judge will review your situation de novo. In other words, the judge will give now weight to the commissioner’s recommendation. In this type of hearing, you would present witnesses and live testimony. There would be cross-examination, opening statements, and closing arguments. It’s very much like a mini-trial.

Be careful and decide which type of hearing you want. If you do not specifically ask for an evidentiary hearing in your objection, your judge will very likely schedule a hearing regarding law only.

If you would like to read the Utah rule of civil procedure that spells out how you object to your commissioner’s recommendation, click here.

Protect Your Money And Your Family

We remove fear associated with divorce, protect your money & maximize time with your kids!

We're here to help. Let's determine your best options.

Call Us 24//7 at 801-685-9999 to Speak with a Live Representative

Utah Divorce FAQs
Top 100 Divorce Blog
What Clients Are Saying…
Brown Family Law
Excellent
4.9
Based on 803 reviews
Overall from start to finish the best experience to have dealing with a time that is difficult.Andrew Christensen is very professional and out going to make this situation the best it could be and worked hard to make sure the divorce was fair for me.Over all, this firm really cares and treats you as a family or friend and just not a client, down to Marco Brown taking time to see how I was doing and offer to help in any way possible during my divorce while I was there for my first initial meeting.I would highly recommend anyone that has to go through a divorce to really reach out to the Brown Family Law firm and see for your self the experience I was able to receive from a top notch law firm.
Response from the owner: Devin, thank you for the kind words. Andrew appreciated the opportunity to help you with your situation.
Sophie was very helpful and explains the process and fees. Thank you!
Response from the owner: Corey, thank you for the kind words. Glad we could help.
My attorney Amy Pomeroy and assistant Melanie and Dani are awesome! It’s an easy case but due to the opposite party was failed to respond, the process went much longer than we expect. During the process Amy gets the necessary job done as quick as she can. The assistants made the most documentation jobs done in a reasonable time. I will get phone call or message to communicate for the status, what’s the next step, what should I expect. In the end, it’s a huge win. So I definitely recommend Brown Family Law. They are professional and handle the case very well.
Response from the owner: Yue, thank you for the kind words. Glad Amy was able to help you so well.
Dani always kept me updated and has great communication skills.
Response from the owner: Thank you, Sofia.
Dani was extremely helpful and always responsive.
Response from the owner: Glad Dani did well for you.
My experience with Brown Family Law is a positive one. I highly recommend them. This firm has very good communication with their clients. Attorney Paul Waldron represents me and I’m very happy with the experience. My questions and concerns are always answered quickly and respectfully. I’m grateful to have Mr. Waldron and Brown Family Law in my corner during this difficult time for my family.
Response from the owner: Jodie, glad we were able to communicate with you so effectively and quickly. Thank you for your kind words.
I recently used Clay in a divorce case and could not have been happier. He was efficient, knowledgeable, and made me feel like I was his only client. The process was easy and he was always there to reassure me or help me with decisions. I would highly recommend Brown Family Law.
Response from the owner: Thank you, Mendi.
Dani excelled as a paralegal, providing crucial support with exceptional skills!
Response from the owner: Glad Dani did such a good job for you.
Thank you So much
Response from the owner: You're welcome. Thank you for choosing us to help you.
I highly recommend Nathaniel and his team. They listened to me, navigated me, educated me, and always called when they said they would. Going through a divorce was very hard but they helped me get through it and showed compassion the whole time.
Response from the owner: Amy, thank you for your recommendation, and glad we could help you through your divorce.
js_loader

Categories

Related Posts