Am I Ready for Divorce? Signs You Might Need to Consider Legal Separation

Are you at a crossroads in your marriage, wondering whether divorce is the right path to take? Making the decision to consider legal separation or divorce is never easy. It’s a momentous and often emotional step that requires careful thought and consideration.

At Brown Family Law, we prioritize finding solutions that work best for you and your family. That’s why we seek to empower you with the information you need to make an informed decision. So, if you are questioning whether it’s time to end your relationship officially, this blog post is for you. We will consider what you need to know about divorce and legal separation.

What You Need to Know About Legal Separation

Many states offer legal separation as an alternative to divorce. In Utah, this legal option is also known as separate maintenance. Separate maintenance allows married couples to live apart while remaining legally married. This option provides a middle ground between staying together and getting a divorce.

Legal separation does not end the marriage, but it does involve legal documentation outlining each spouse’s rights and responsibilities during the separation period. This structured approach can help minimize conflicts and ensure clarity on important matters like child custody, support payments, and property division.

When to Consider Legal Separation

Are you at a point in your marriage where the constant arguments and disagreements seem never-ending? Do you find yourself feeling emotionally drained and disconnected from your spouse more often than not?

If communication has broken down and attempts to resolve conflicts only lead to further tension, legal separation could provide some much-needed breathing room. Feeling like you’re living with a stranger rather than a partner can be a clear indicator that the relationship needs reevaluation.

Monetary issues, such as the mismanagement of money or financial abuse, may indicate the need for legal intervention. Additionally, if issues such as infidelity or substance abuse are present in the relationship and have not been effectively addressed through therapy or counseling, separate maintenance could offer a path toward healing and self-discovery.

The following are reasons why some spouses consider legal separation:

  • Separate maintenance can provide space and time for both parties to evaluate their feelings and assess whether divorce is truly the best solution
  • Unlike divorce proceedings where the marriage is terminated, separate maintenance can be an alternative for those who hope to reconcile in the future or for personal or religious reasons
  • Separate maintenance allows for tax benefits that may not be available in divorce proceedings
  • Separate maintenance also provides financial protection by outlining responsibilities regarding assets and debts during the separation period

Deciding whether legal separation or divorce is the better choice depends on individual circumstances and goals within a relationship. Of course, before being granted separate maintenance, certain requirements must be met.

Petitioning for Separate Maintenance in Utah

Understanding the criteria for requesting separate maintenance in Utah is essential for couples navigating challenging marital circumstances.

In Utah, you may petition for separate maintenance in the case of:

  • Desertion: Your spouse has deserted you without good cause
  • Failure to support: Your spouse is capable of supporting you but fails to do so
  • Living apart: Through no fault of your own, you and your spouse are living apart
  • Spouse in prison: Your spouse has been imprisoned for 1 year or more and has not provided for you
  • Property in Utah: As a resident of Utah, your spouse owns property in the state and does not support you

How Child Support and Alimony is Handled During Legal Separation

In a legal separation or separate maintenance agreement, both parties may still be eligible for child support if there are children involved. The court will determine the amount based on various factors, such as income and custody arrangements.

On the other hand, in a divorce proceeding, child support is typically mandated by the court before finalizing the dissolution of marriage. Alimony, also known as spousal support, can vary between separate maintenance and divorce cases. In legal separation agreements, alimony may be awarded depending on individual circumstances. However, in divorce proceedings in Utah, alimony is often determined during property division discussions.

Utah Laws on Property Division for Separate Maintenance vs. Divorce

During legal separation, spouses retain their marital status, meaning assets and debts acquired during the separation remain jointly owned unless otherwise specified in a separation agreement. The court can allocate property and debts between spouses based on equitable principles. This division aims to ensure fairness rather than strict equality, taking into account factors such as each spouse’s financial contributions, needs, and future earning capacities.

Spouses can negotiate a separation agreement that outlines how debts and property acquired during marriage will be divided. This agreement can include provisions for the division of real estate, financial accounts, retirement assets, and personal property.

In a divorce, the marital property is divided permanently as the marriage is officially ended. Like legal separation, divorce in Utah follows the principle of equitable distribution rather than equal division. The court considers various factors to divide marital property fairly, including the duration of the marriage, each spouse’s financial circumstances, contributions to the marriage, and any agreements made between the spouses.

The Tax Implications of Separate Maintenance vs. Divorce in Utah

Understanding the tax implications of separate maintenance (legal separation) versus divorce in Utah is crucial for making informed decisions about your financial future. While both legal processes address the division of assets, child custody, and spousal support, they can have different effects on your taxes.

Here’s what you need to know.

Filing status

When legally separated, you can still file as married, filing jointly, or married filing separately. However, you may also qualify for head of household status if you meet certain conditions, such as paying more than half the cost of maintaining your home and having a qualifying dependent.

Once divorced, you must file as single or, if you have a qualifying dependent, head of household. This change in filing status can significantly impact your tax benefits.

Alimony and spousal support

In general, alimony payments made under a separate maintenance agreement are generally tax-deductible for the payer and taxable income for the recipient, provided the agreement was executed before December 31, 2018. For agreements executed after this date, alimony payments are neither deductible by the payer nor taxable to the recipient, due to changes in tax law.

The same tax rules apply to alimony payments in the context of divorce. It’s important to specify the terms clearly in the separation agreement or divorce decree to ensure proper tax treatment.

As for child support, these payments are not tax-deductible for the payer – nor are they considered taxable income for the recipient. This rule is consistent regardless of whether you are legally separated or divorced.

Dependency exemptions and tax credits

For separate maintenance, you and your spouse must decide who will claim your kids as dependents on your tax returns. Typically, this decision is outlined in the separate maintenance agreement. The parent who claims the children may be eligible for tax benefits such as the Child Tax Credit, the Earned Income Tax Credit, and the Child and Dependent Care Credit.

The divorce decree may specify who claims the children as dependents since parents with custody generally claim their children on tax returns.

Health insurance

Legally separated spouses may still be eligible for coverage under a family health insurance plan, depending on the terms of the plan. However, some plans may require a change in coverage.

After a divorce, spouses are no longer eligible for coverage under each other’s health insurance plans. You will need to explore other options, such as COBRA or obtaining your own insurance plan.

Understanding these tax implications is crucial when deciding between separate maintenance or divorce proceedings. However, depending on your situation, there may be other tax issues to consider. With the guidance of your legal team, you should consult a tax professional or financial advisor to fully grasp how divorce or separation could affect your tax obligations.

How to Prepare Yourself for a Legal Separation

Going through a legal separation can be an emotionally taxing experience. It may be especially taxing since it’s not a long-term solution for many couples.

In Utah, legal separation only lasts for 1 year and, if you wish to prolong it, you must file another petition. Yet, if you feel that legal separation is the right choice for you, here’s how you can navigate the journey ahead of you.

Gather necessary documentation

Preparing for a legal separation involves collecting all pertinent documents, including:

  • Marriage certificate
  • Financial statements (bank accounts, investments)
  • Tax returns (last three years)
  • Property deeds and titles
  • Pay stubs and employment records
  • Insurance policies
  • Any existing prenuptial or postnuptial agreements

Organize your finances

Being financially stable is a significant concern during a legal separation. Start by gathering all financial documents, including bank statements and property deeds. Create a budget to understand your expenses and consider meeting with a financial advisor to plan for your future. If necessary, open a separate bank account to manage your finances independently.

Consider temporary orders

While the legal separation process is ongoing, you can request temporary orders from the court. These orders address immediate concerns such as who will stay in the marital home, temporary child custody arrangements, and temporary financial support. Temporary orders help maintain stability and clarity during the separation proceedings.

Attend mediation and all required classes

In Utah, mediation or divorce education classes are often required to help separating couples resolve disputes amicably. During mediation, a neutral third party will work with you and your current spouse to reach agreements on contentious issues. This process can save time and reduce the emotional and financial costs associated with lengthy court battles.

Are You Ready for Divorce?

Choosing to end your marriage permanently is a weighty decision – one that you have likely considered carefully. Still, it’s good to take a step back and evaluate your situation throughout the legal process. Reflect on the reasons driving you towards this decision.

Consider seeking counseling or therapy to explore any underlying issues in your marriage that could potentially be resolved. Think about the impact of divorce not only on yourself but also on your children, if applicable.

Assess your financial situation and determine how assets and debts will be divided post-separation. Additionally, consider your living arrangements post-divorce, including housing, relocation if necessary, and adjustments to your lifestyle. Evaluate practical aspects such as custody arrangements, division of household items, and logistical changes.

Consulting with a family law attorney can provide valuable insight into what to expect during the divorce process. With the help of your legal team, familiarize yourself with your rights and responsibilities. Take time to consider alternative options such as mediation or collaborative divorce before proceeding with litigation.

Making the Right Choice for Your Future

Making such life-changing decisions about your marriage requires careful consideration. Remember that every situation is unique, and what works for one couple may not be the best choice for another.

By understanding the differences between legal separation and divorce in Utah, evaluating your circumstances, considering your children’s well-being, and prioritizing your financial interests, you can make informed decisions that will shape your future post-marriage.

Only you can determine which choice is right for your situation. Whether you choose separate maintenance or decide that divorce is the best path forward, Brown Family Law is here to assist you every step of the way as you explore legal options to protect yourself, your children, and your assets.

Let our team support you in this new chapter of your life. Call the family attorneys of Brown Family Law today at 801-685-9999 or fill out our online form to schedule a divorce consultation.

Protect Your Money And Your Family

We remove fear associated with divorce, protect your money & maximize time with your kids!

We're here to help. Let's determine your best options.

Call Us 24//7 at 801-685-9999 to Speak with a Live Representative

Utah Divorce FAQs
Top 100 Divorce Blog
What Clients Are Saying…
Brown Family Law
Based on 807 reviews
I would hands down suggest Brown Family Law. Nathaniel helped me with my divorce, and he was very knowlegeable and knows his stuff. He helped me file a motion, get somethings changed in the original decree, helped me understand the terms they use, helped me understand how child support is calculated along is all the financial aspects associated with divorce case. He also is very responsive to phone calls and emails which was very helpful whenever I had small questions. Thank you Nathaniel!
Response from the owner: Andrew, thank you for your kind words.
I can’t say enough good things about Brown Family Law, but more specifically, my lawyer David Handy and his paralegal Dani. They are kind and honest and always available to me when I’ve needed them! This is such an exhausting time and they alleviated all of my stress by taking control. I could trust the process knowing I was in great hands!!! The entire law firm works as a team to take care of you! I can’t recommend them enough! Thank you!!!
Response from the owner: Ryan, so glad David and Dani served you so well and alleviated your stress.
They handled my case with the highest degree of professionalism and integrity and made every effort to be efficient and transparent with me throughout the whole process. I was told that they were the best as far as family law is concerned and I believe that praise was fully justified.
Response from the owner: Ben, thank you.
Amber McFee is always professional and great to work with. Being opposing counsel by nature is adversarial, but Amber is professional in approach while effectively advocating for her clients. She will treat you right!
Response from the owner: Thank you, Jonathan.
Overall from start to finish the best experience to have dealing with a time that is difficult.Andrew Christensen is very professional and out going to make this situation the best it could be and worked hard to make sure the divorce was fair for me.Over all, this firm really cares and treats you as a family or friend and just not a client, down to Marco Brown taking time to see how I was doing and offer to help in any way possible during my divorce while I was there for my first initial meeting.I would highly recommend anyone that has to go through a divorce to really reach out to the Brown Family Law firm and see for your self the experience I was able to receive from a top notch law firm.
Response from the owner: Devin, thank you for the kind words. Andrew appreciated the opportunity to help you with your situation.
Sophie was very helpful and explains the process and fees. Thank you!
Response from the owner: Corey, thank you for the kind words. Glad we could help.
Dani always kept me updated and has great communication skills.
Response from the owner: Thank you, Sofia.
Dani was extremely helpful and always responsive.
Response from the owner: Glad Dani did well for you.
My experience with Brown Family Law is a positive one. I highly recommend them. This firm has very good communication with their clients. Attorney Paul Waldron represents me and I’m very happy with the experience. My questions and concerns are always answered quickly and respectfully. I’m grateful to have Mr. Waldron and Brown Family Law in my corner during this difficult time for my family.
Response from the owner: Jodie, glad we were able to communicate with you so effectively and quickly. Thank you for your kind words.
I recently used Clay in a divorce case and could not have been happier. He was efficient, knowledgeable, and made me feel like I was his only client. The process was easy and he was always there to reassure me or help me with decisions. I would highly recommend Brown Family Law.
Response from the owner: Thank you, Mendi.